Sympathetic Magic
Photo by Ella Olsson on Unsplash
A few days after her funeral, I was cleaning out my mother’s desk. The usual detritus was there: business cards, stamps, envelopes, stationery, and carefully clipped newspaper articles stacked in neat piles. These were her tools of the trade, the ordinary objects that had passed through her hands so often they still seemed to hold the shape of her fingers.
Opening the center drawer, I found a letter my mother had written, dated just two weeks before her death. Her familiar handwriting made me ache instantly. I thought I was done with crying by then. I was not.
I paused before reading it. Was I infringing on her privacy? The dead deserve certain dignities. I thought I should just put the letter into the shoebox with the other keepsakes and leave it unread forever. I nearly did, but wanting to hear her voice, even if it was through a letter, convinced me to read on.
The letter was addressed to Jeff Smith, otherwise known as the Frugal Gourmet. My mother had always loved cooking shows, and in her vernacular, “frugal” did not mean cheap. It meant reverent. It meant nothing was wasted. Not food, not time, not affection.
Writing a letter in longhand is intimate in a way that emails and text messages will never fully replicate. The loops and slants of handwriting carry personality. A handwritten letter records hesitation, emphasis, even mood. The pressure of the pen changes when someone is excited or tired or emotional. Receiving such a letter feels almost sacred because the recipient knows time was spent in its creation.
I have most of the letters people have written to me over the years. I have love letters tied with ribbon. I have notes from my children written in uncertain handwriting when they were young. I have postcards mailed from distant cities, their corners softened with age. I keep them all in a special place, an old hand-painted wooden box with a brass latch. They are mine and nobody else’s, tiny, preserved moments from lives intersecting with my own.
In her letter, my mother explains to Jeff Smith how much pleasure his show had given her during an illness that had confined her to bed. She writes in a conversational and slightly flirtatious style, joking that she knows he likes women like her, the kind who have “onions in their drawers.” I could hear her voice as I read it. I could hear the rhythm of her humor.
She ended her letter with Smith’s signature close: “I bid you peace.”
When we write a letter, it becomes a form of sympathetic magic. According to Merriam-Webster, sympathetic magic is based on the assumption that a person or thing can be supernaturally affected by an object representing it. Anthropologists often describe it as the belief that objects retain a connection to the people who once touched them. A lock of hair. A photograph. A cherished possession.
A handwritten letter certainly exceeds this criterion. Holding that paper in my hands, I could feel my mother’s presence so strongly it startled me. Not metaphorically. Physically. The letter became a kind of bridge between the living and the dead.
Grief does strange things to our senses. The dead return through scent, sound, and texture. Sometimes I catch the smell of her perfume unexpectedly in a department store aisle and feel my chest tightening. Often, I hear a phrase she used to say emerge from my own mouth before I even realize it. But handwriting is different because it is so distinctly individual. No one else formed letters exactly the way my mother did.
And she was such a good cook. I can still almost taste it. Saturday mornings at our house revolved around watching Julia Child on television. The French Chef was not to be missed. I would sit beside my mother and watch Julia wield wooden spoons and enormous knives with fearless delight. But more than watching Julia, I watched my mother. I watched her attention sharpen. I watched her imagination engage.
Then we would head into the kitchen ourselves. We prepared soufflés that rose magnificently in the oven. Lamb chops sizzling in butter. Bouillabaisse fragrant with saffron. Even Peking duck, ambitious and glorious and far too complicated for ordinary people, which of course made my mother determined to try it. I was the kitchen helper, a role I held until the day she died.
The kitchen was my mother’s domain, but it was also her language of love. Some people say “I love you” with words. My mother said it with meals. She said it through carefully chopped onions, simmering soups, and pies cooling on the counter. She said it by making sure everyone had enough.
When I got married, she gave me a copy of The Joy of Cooking as a wedding present. At the time, it felt practical. Years later, I understood it was also ceremonial, a passing down of knowledge from one woman to another. I gave my copy to my daughter Grace when she married.
Even at the end of her life, when illness made it difficult for her to eat solid food herself, my mother still found joy in cooking for other people. I remember the strange heartbreak of watching her prepare meals she could no longer enjoy. Yet somehow the giving mattered more than the eating.
There is sympathetic magic in cooking too. Food carries memory more powerfully than almost anything else. One bite of a familiar dish can collapse decades of time. We taste our childhood again. We taste holidays and birthdays and even ordinary Tuesday nights at the dinner table. When someone cooks with love, people feel it, even if they cannot explain why.
The same is true of letters. Perhaps that is why we save them. We understand instinctively that certain objects become infused with emotion. A recipe card in a mother’s handwriting becomes priceless. A margin note in a beloved book becomes a form of haunting. These objects outlive the body, carrying fragments of personality forward through time.
Reading my mother’s letter, I realized how much human beings want to leave traces of themselves behind. Not monuments or grand achievements, necessarily. Just evidence that we were here and that we cared.
I folded my mother’s four-page letter carefully along its original creases. Then I found the address for the Frugal Gourmet, placed the pages back into their envelope, stamped and sealed it.
Maybe it was irrational to mail a letter written by someone who was already gone. Maybe it was too late. Standing there alone in the quiet kitchen, with tears still fresh in my eyes, it felt it was important that her words continue traveling through the world a little longer. Wiping away the last of my tears, I walked out the front door and down the street to the mailbox, carrying my mother with me.
Editor: Lia Cook
Comments
When you mailed the letter, was Jeff Smith already dead? That would have made it even more poignant.